Understanding the value of a pre-revenue startup presents unique challenges, but scenario analysis offers a structured approach to this uncertainty. Scenario analysis are based on a range of estimated valuations based on various growth paths and market conditions. This approach is particularly valuable for early-stage startups that lack historical data, as it allows founders to quantify their assumptions and create defensible valuations based on multiple possible outcomes. They are also a viable option to supplement tax planning strategies and can be used to justify favorable employee incentive plan structures.
Process and preparation
These analyses serve two crucial purposes. First, they provide founders and potential investors with a framework for understanding the startup’s potential value range. Rather than settling on a single valuation number, which could be misleading for a pre-revenue company, scenario analysis acknowledges uncertainty while providing structured insights into possible outcomes.
The process begins with developing key scenarios, typically including conservative, moderate, and optimistic projections. More complex models may incorporate a ‘scenario matrix’ which puts together a range of exit dates against a range of exit values. Having a waterfall at hand is vital as it enables you to specifically determine the ‘expected value’ that each participant will be paid in these scenarios. This forms the basis for tax-oriented scenario analyses, and provide a foundation for the estimated value of the planned incentive strategy.
With an in-depth analysis for your business and including a systemic approach to its modelling, you may incorporate different assumptions about market penetration, customer acquisition costs, pricing strategies, and operational efficiency. For example, a software startup might model scenarios ranging from capturing 1% to 5% of their target market over three years, with varying customer acquisition costs and retention rates. However, most early-stage startups benefit simply from comparing their expected EBITDAs with market multiples already!
Use cases for incentive plans
These analyses strengthen tax planning documentation: When establishing initial share prices or creating stock option plans, tax authorities often require evidence supporting your chosen valuations. Well-documented scenario analyses, especially when they incorporate market comparables and industry benchmarks, help justify your valuation assumptions to tax authorities. Not all jurisdictions are familiar with scenario analyses, however, the Dutch Tax Authorities are known to be amicable toward their inclusion in particular for pre-revenue startups.
Leave a Reply